Bigfoot/Werewolf in Holy Hill, Wisconsin (Recent!)

http://www.gmtoday.com/news/local_stories/2006/Nov_06/11102006_06.asp
and
http://www.cnb-scene.com/braybearwolf.html

What do you think? I am a completely open minded person when it comes to the supernatural, BUT I still use logic before jumping into conclusions. 1st of all let me say this. Holy Hill is a creepy little town where if you get lost in the woods, don't be surprised if you start to hear banjo music and a guy squealing like a pig. (Sorry to affend those of you that live in this area, but hearing conversations by some of the locals you'd agree with me.)
It's fun to talk about "Bigfoot, werewolves, ufos and ghosts" but come on.. Think seriously here for a second people. These so called "spottings" have been taking place since the beginning of time and yet, not one of any of these "animals" or "beasts" or "entities" has ever been caught. Ghosts I look at a little differently because people have audio and visual "evidence". But even still, there are sOOOO many hoaxers that it's impossible now adays to "prove" anything.
One point I'd like to personally make here, I found it interesting this guy that picks up road carcass at 1am never got tested for alcohol or drugs in his blood. Not assuming he is "under the influence" of course but really, all aspects should be covered. He didn't have the best lighting, it was in the middle of the night and fatigue may have set in.. And fatigue can equal hallucinations, and well, if he had anything to drink... Yeah.. That's all that needs to be said. But you watch now.. Tons of people will come forward with their little stories. Funny it all comes out now. Publicity pays well and the power of suggestion is misleading.
14 years ago when I first moved to the country in Wisconsin I heard rumors of a werewolf running around.. After that died down, nothing until now. I'm sure that if something that fricken huge (either bigfoot or a werewolf) was running around for this long we sure as hell would have seen it. Especially all you trigger happy murderous hunters that shoot anything that moves, including your own foot.

Here's my skeptical version:
Guy sets out to pick up his dead deer with little to no sleep. Pops a couple of his meds and grabs his thermos of coffee and kesslers. Gets to that area where the deer is, perhaps just, knocked unconsious, not remembering if it's on his "route" or not, but picks it up anyways. Groggy, and forgetful he forgets to put his truck ramp into the bed of the truck. Listening to his banjo cd, he hears a thump and looks behind him.. What's actually happening is either A) deer regained consciousness and is confused and scared and stumbles off the truckbed or B) deer's body starts to twitch and contort. This guy looks for 5 seconds in dim light, with a groggy perception and poor understanding and floors the gas peddle which in turn hurls the deer out of the truck. Which then runs off or crawls to ditch, high grass, forest or whatever! Realizing he forgot his ramp, and that would come out of his paycheck, he goes back and it's mysteriously "gone". (Because of course the werewolf or bigfoot or whatever needs a truck ramp.) No way in hell any passing motorist would have taken it. ( Good Christmas gift)

Believer version: Guys saw what he saw. We don't know everything. There is so much out there we haven't discovered yet, but that doesn't mean it hasn't discovered us.